489

Not to stand idly by if someone's life is in danger

The Luchos - Ten Commandments

This page is incomplete.
Help complete the
Mitzvah Minute website.

Mitzvah Minute Logo Icon
פָּרָשַׁת קְדֹשִׁים
-
:לֹֽא־תֵלֵ֤ךְ רָכִיל֙ בְּעַמֶּ֔יךָ לֹ֥א תַֽעֲמֹ֖ד עַל־דַּ֣ם רֵעֶ֑ךָ אֲנִ֖י יְהוָֹֽה
Leviticus 19:16
-
You shall not go around as a gossipmonger amidst your people. You shall not stand by [the shedding of] your fellow's blood. I am the Lord.
Saving someones life from drowning

This Mitzvah's Summary

מִצְוָה עֲשֵׂה - Positive Commandment
מִצְוָה לֹא תַעֲשֶׂה - Negative Commandment
Between a person and their fellow – בֵּין אָדָם לַחֲבֵרוֹ

It is forbidden to remain passive when another person’s life is at risk; one must act to save them whenever possible.

This mitzvah establishes that life-saving responsibility is not optional. When a person witnesses danger — physical, emotional, or existential — silence and inaction become moral failures. The Torah does not merely prohibit causing harm; it forbids indifference. “Do not stand idly by” demands intervention, advocacy, and courage. A Jew is obligated to step forward, even at personal cost, when another’s life or dignity hangs in the balance. This mitzvah transforms compassion into duty and responsibility into action.

Commentaries

Rambam

  • Source: Sefer HaMitzvos, Lo Ta’aseh 297; Hilchos Rotzeach u’Shmiras HaNefesh 1:14–16. Rambam rules that anyone who can save another person — through physical intervention, warning, counsel, or mobilizing others — and fails to do so violates this prohibition. The mitzvah includes saving someone from attackers, wild animals, drowning, or any foreseeable danger. Inaction is treated as moral participation in harm.

Sefer HaChinuch

  • Mitzvah 237. Chinuch explains that this commandment trains the soul toward mercy and responsibility. A society that tolerates passivity in the face of danger erodes its moral core. By obligating action, the Torah creates a community bound by mutual responsibility, where every life is guarded by all.

Rashi / Ramban / Ibn Ezra / Sforno / Abarbanel / Midrashim

  • Rashi explains that “standing” implies conscious delay — seeing danger and choosing not to respond.
  • Ramban expands the scope beyond physical bloodshed to include legal, emotional, and social danger — silence can destroy a person as effectively as violence.
  • Ibn Ezra emphasizes that the verse speaks in immediate language: when danger is present, neutrality is forbidden.
  • Sforno frames the mitzvah as covenantal loyalty — refusing to abandon one’s fellow when their life is threatened.
  • Abarbanel teaches that moral societies collapse when people outsource responsibility; the Torah makes every individual accountable.
  • Midrashim describe this mitzvah as the antidote to cruelty disguised as politeness or restraint.

Talmud & Midrash

  • Sanhedrin 73a derives that one must actively intervene to save another, even incurring financial cost or personal risk. The Gemara expands the obligation to include preventing harm through testimony, warning, and strategic action.
  • Yerushalmi teaches that failure to act when able is considered bloodshed by omission.

Kuzari, Maharal, and Other Rishonim

  • Kuzari links this mitzvah to covenantal solidarity — Israel survives because Jews refuse to abandon one another.
  • Maharal explains that life is sacred because it reflects Divine will; allowing preventable destruction fractures the moral fabric of creation.
  • Other Rishonim note that passivity normalizes injustice and trains the soul toward indifference.

Shulchan Aruch & Practical Ramifications

  • Choshen Mishpat 426 codifies this mitzvah: one must warn others of danger, intervene when possible, and even hire help to rescue someone in peril.
  • Poskim rule that professional knowledge (medical, legal, technical) increases responsibility — the more one can help, the greater the obligation.

Acharonim & Modern Torah Giants

  • Chasam Sofer warns that “respecting boundaries” must never become an excuse for moral silence.
  • Netziv teaches that societies are judged not by kindness spoken, but by lives protected.
  • Rav Hirsch emphasizes that Torah morality rejects bystander culture — responsibility is shared, not optional.
  • Chafetz Chaim applies this mitzvah to speech: silence in the face of danger caused by misinformation or slander can be lethal.

Chassidic & Mussar Classics

  • Baal Shem Tov teaches that souls are interconnected; refusing to act for another damages one’s own spiritual integrity.
  • Tanya frames responsibility as an expression of unity — when one Jew bleeds, all are diminished.
  • Sfas Emes writes that courage is holiness in motion — faith that moves the body, not just the mind.
  • Ramchal explains that true piety demands readiness to sacrifice comfort for truth and life.

Contrast with Mitzvah 490 — To rescue one pursued

  • Mitzvah 489 forbids passivity.
  • Mitzvah 490 mandates active rescue, even through force if necessary.
    Together they define the full Torah ethic of life protection.

Parallel to Pikuach Nefesh

  • This mitzvah underpins the principle that saving life overrides nearly all prohibitions.
  • Pikuach nefesh is not only reactive; it demands foresight and intervention.
(Source: Chabad.org)

Applying this Mitzvah Today

Moral Courage Over Comfort

  • This mitzvah rejects the modern instinct to “stay out of it.” When harm is foreseeable — abuse, exploitation, self-destruction, or isolation — silence is complicity. Torah ethics demand presence, not detachment.

Emotional and Psychological Danger

  • Life-threatening danger includes emotional collapse and despair. Reaching out, checking in, and refusing to ignore warning signs fulfills this mitzvah in contemporary form.

Communal Responsibility

  • Schools, shuls, workplaces, and families are obligated to create cultures where danger is addressed, not hidden. Policies that prioritize reputation over safety violate this commandment.

Digital Bystanding

  • Online harassment, doxxing, and public shaming can destroy lives. This mitzvah applies equally in digital spaces — one must intervene, report, and defend.

Yehudah’s Model of Responsibility

  • Yehudah’s declaration “I will be guarantor for the lad” exemplifies this mitzvah: responsibility that binds one’s fate to another’s survival.

This Mitzvah's Divrei Torah

"Geulah as Process, Not Event — Part III"

Oppression by Paperwork: Pharaoh’s “Wisdom” and the Bureaucracy of Evil

5 - min read

Oppression by Paperwork: Pharaoh’s “Wisdom” and the Bureaucracy of Evil

A Sefer Torah
Read
January 4, 2026

"The Anti-Murder Axis — Part III"

Moshe and the Egyptian: When Stopping Violence Raises New Questions

5 - min read

Moshe and the Egyptian: When Stopping Violence Raises New Questions

A Sefer Torah
Read
January 3, 2026

"The Anti-Murder Axis — Part II"

“וַתְּחַיֶּיןָ” — The Midwives Who Didn’t Just Refuse: They Gave Life

5 - min read

“וַתְּחַיֶּיןָ” — The Midwives Who Didn’t Just Refuse: They Gave Life

A Sefer Torah
Read
January 3, 2026

"The Anti-Murder Axis — Part I"

Mitzvah #482 — Not to Murder: The Parsha Built on the Refusal to Kill

5 - min read

Mitzvah #482 — Not to Murder: The Parsha Built on the Refusal to Kill

A Sefer Torah
Read
January 3, 2026

"Yehudah’s Kingship: Leadership Earned Through Admission"

Parshas Vayechi — How Moral Courage, Not Power, Creates Malchus

4 - min read

Parshas Vayechi — How Moral Courage, Not Power, Creates Malchus

A Sefer Torah
Read
December 28, 2025

Notes on this Mitzvah's Fundamentals

Murder – רוֹצֵחַ

  • This mitzvah stands as the Torah’s preventative counterweight to murder, obligating intervention before blood is spilled. Rambam explains that failing to act when life is threatened is a form of indirect participation in murder itself. By commanding proactive rescue, the Torah reframes murder not only as an act of violence, but as a failure of responsibility. Preserving life requires vigilance, courage, and readiness to intervene when danger arises.

Justice – צֶדֶק

  • Justice in the Torah is not limited to courtroom rulings; it extends into the moral duty of every individual. The Sifra teaches that “לֹא תַעֲמֹד עַל דַּם רֵעֶךָ” establishes justice as preventative, not reactive. A society that allows preventable harm to occur is unjust even if courts later punish the offender. This mitzvah demands that justice begin with protection, not punishment.

Compassion – רַחֲמִים

  • Compassion here is not emotional sympathy but decisive action. Chazal teach that true rachamim is expressed by saving life, even at personal cost or inconvenience. Ramban emphasizes that Torah compassion refuses neutrality in the face of danger. Allowing harm through inaction is cruelty disguised as passivity; the Torah therefore commands active mercy.

Community – קְהִלָּה

  • This mitzvah defines Jewish society as mutually responsible. No individual is permitted to retreat into private concern when another’s life is endangered. The Netziv explains that Torah community is built on shared guardianship of life, where each person functions as a protector of the other. Silence or withdrawal fractures communal covenant.

Laws and Courts – דִּינִים

  • While courts punish murder after the fact, this mitzvah precedes judicial process. The Mechilta explains that Torah law assigns responsibility before the judge is involved. Legal systems alone cannot preserve life; they must be reinforced by personal duty. Thus, halacha integrates civil law with moral obligation.

Between a Person and Their Fellow – בֵּין אָדָם לַחֲבֵרוֹ

  • At its core, this mitzvah demands radical interpersonal responsibility. One must intervene to save another regardless of relationship, status, or convenience. Chafetz Chaim stresses that neglecting rescue is a grave interpersonal sin, even when no hostility exists. Neutrality in danger violates brotherhood.

Between a Person and G-d – בֵּין אָדָם לְמָקוֹם

  • Saving life is not only a human obligation but an act of avodas Hashem. Rambam frames this mitzvah as obedience to the Divine will that human life reflect Divine image. Standing idly by rejects Hashem’s command to protect His creation, making inaction a breach in one’s relationship with Him.

Reverence – יִרְאַת שָׁמַיִם

  • One who truly fears Hashem cannot ignore mortal danger. The Talmud teaches that reverence manifests through moral restraint and action. When a Jew intervenes to save life, he demonstrates awareness that Hashem observes human responsibility. Fear of Heaven transforms courage into obligation.

Holiness – קְדֻשָּׁה

  • Holiness is expressed through protecting life, not retreating from the world. Sefer HaChinuch explains that kedushah elevates physical reality by safeguarding it. By acting to save another, a person sanctifies daily life and affirms that holiness resides in moral action.

Martyrdom – קִידּוּשׁ הַשֵּׁם

  • Refusing to stand idly by affirms the supreme value of life created by Hashem. In extreme cases, risking oneself to save another becomes a form of Kiddush Hashem. The Torah teaches that loyalty to Hashem is expressed not only in belief, but in willingness to act when life is at stake.

Faith – אֱמוּנָה

  • Emunah here is trust that Hashem demands responsibility, not passivity. A believer understands that Divine providence does not excuse human inaction. By intervening, a Jew affirms that Hashem entrusted life into human care, requiring partnership rather than fatalism.

Core Beliefs – יְסוֹדוֹת הָאֱמוּנָה

  • This mitzvah reinforces the foundational belief that every human life bears Divine image and infinite value. Rambam includes preservation of life among the axioms of Torah ethics. Denying responsibility for another’s danger undermines the Torah’s vision of moral humanity.

Thought – מַחֲשָׁבָה

  • The Torah forbids not only physical passivity but mental withdrawal. Rambam teaches that recognizing danger and rationalizing inaction is itself a violation. Thought shapes action; therefore, moral awareness must immediately translate into responsibility.

This Mitzvah's Fundamental Badges

Justice – צֶדֶק

Information Icon

Mitzvot that uphold fairness, honesty, and moral responsibility. Justice is kindness structured — ensuring that society reflects G-d’s order through truth, equity, and accountability.

View Badge →

Compassion – רַחֲמִים

Information Icon

Empathy in motion — responding to another’s pain with sensitivity, patience, and understanding. Whereas chesed gives broadly, rachamim responds gently, tailoring care to a person’s emotional or spiritual needs.

View Badge →

Community – קְהִלָּה

Information Icon

Mitzvot that strengthen communal life — showing up, participating, supporting, and belonging. Community is where holiness is shared, prayers are multiplied, and responsibility becomes collective.

View Badge →

Between a person and their fellow - בֵּין אָדָם לַחֲבֵרוֹ

Information Icon

Mitzvot that govern ethical behavior, kindness, justice, and responsibility in human relationships. These actions build trust, dignity, and peace between people.

View Badge →

Between a person and G-d - בֵּין אָדָם לְמָקוֹם

Information Icon

Mitzvot that define and deepen the relationship between a person and their Creator. These include commandments involving belief, prayer, Shabbat, festivals, sacrifices, and personal holiness — expressions of devotion rooted in divine connection.

View Badge →

Reverence - יִרְאַת שָׁמַיִם

Information Icon

Signifies awe and reverence toward Hashem—living with awareness of His greatness and presence.

View Badge →

Holiness - קְדֻשָּׁה

Information Icon

Represents the concept of  spiritual intentionality, purity, and sanctity—set apart for a higher purpose.

View Badge →

Martyrdom - קִידּוּשׁ הַשֵּׁם

Information Icon

Represents sanctifying G‑d’s Name—even to the point of self-sacrifice when necessary.

View Badge →

Faith - אֱמוּנָה

Information Icon

Represents Emunah—the deep, inner trust in Hashem’s presence, oneness, and constant involvement in our lives. This badge symbolizes a heartfelt connection to G-d, rooted in belief even when we cannot see. It is the emotional and spiritual core of many mitzvot.

View Badge →

Core Beliefs - יְסוֹדוֹת הָאֱמוּנָה

Information Icon

Used for mitzvot that reflect Judaism’s foundational principles—belief in G-d, reward and punishment, prophecy, Torah from Heaven, and more. These commandments shape the lens through which all others are understood.

View Badge →

Thought - מַחֲשָׁבָה

Information Icon

Relates to internal intentions, beliefs, and mindfulness in performing mitzvot or avoiding transgressions.

View Badge →
Mitzvah Minute
Mitzvah Minute Logo

Learn more.

Dive into mitzvos, prayer, and Torah study—each section curated to help you learn, reflect, and live with intention. New insights are added regularly, creating an evolving space for spiritual growth.

Luchos
Live a commandment-driven life

Mitzvah

Explore the 613 mitzvos and uncover the meaning behind each one. Discover practical ways to integrate them into your daily life with insights, sources, and guided reflection.

Learn more

Mitzvah #

5

To fear Him
The Luchos - Ten Commandments
Learn this Mitzvah

Mitzvah Highlight

Siddur
Connection through Davening

Tefillah

Learn the structure, depth, and spiritual intent behind Jewish prayer. Dive into morning blessings, Shema, Amidah, and more—with tools to enrich your daily connection.

Learn more

Tefillah

COMING SOON.
A Siddur
Learn this Tefillah

Tefillah Focus

A Sefer Torah
Study the weekly Torah portion

Parsha

Each week’s parsha offers timeless wisdom and modern relevance. Explore summaries, key themes, and mitzvah connections to deepen your understanding of the Torah cycle.

Learn more

וָאֵרָא – Va’eira

Haftarah: Ezekiel 28:25 - 29:21
A Sefer Torah
Learn this Parsha

Weekly Parsha